A group of eight
Democratic and Republican senators unveiled key elements Monday of a
proposed compromise to reform the U.S. immigration system. President
Barack Obama will use an event in Nevada on Tuesday to lay out his
vision on the issue.
What the Senate lawmakers called “tough but fair” proposals would
accomplish key objectives Obama and previous presidents have long
supported, including a path to citizenship for 11 million illegal
immigrants in the United States.
The plan specifically links eventual citizenship with future steps to
enhance border security. Immigrants seeking a "green card" - the
document needed to work legally - would have to satisfy all
requirements, such as payment of taxes and any outstanding fines, and
demonstrate their English-language ability.
Also included are steps Obama has advocated to boost the U.S. economy,
by ending a talent drain in which the children of illegal immigrants who
acquired an education and skills - and their parents - are forced to
leave the United States.
Press Secretary Jay Carney welcomed the framework, but he declined to
discuss legislative timetables or even say if Obama will propose a bill
himself. Carney said conditions appear right for progress.
“He believes that we are at a moment now where there seems to be support
coalescing at a bipartisan level behind the very principles that he has
long put forward," he said.
Carney said Obama's remarks Tuesday in Nevada, a state he won in the
2008 and 2012 presidential elections with strong Hispanic and labor
union support, will engage Americans in a conversation about the
Democratic and Republican congressional aides said the Senate plan was
deliberately released now to provide political separation from Mr. Obama
and demonstrate that Congress is determined to act.
Obama spoke about immigration reform in his second inaugural address.
“Our journey is not complete until we find a better way to welcome the
striving, hopeful immigrants who still see America as a land of
opportunity, until bright young students and engineers are enlisted in
our workforce rather than expelled from our country," he said.
Congressional proposals include further strengthening of border
security, steps to prevent employers from hiring illegal immigrants and
bolstering measures to prevent identity theft.
The Senate plan would give green cards to immigrants who obtain advanced
degrees at U.S. universities. Agricultural workers would be treated
differently from other undocumented immigrants. Employers would be
allowed to to hire immigrants if citizens cannot be found.
Calling their framework a first step, senators said a tough fight lies
ahead, but that they are confident immigration reform can be achieved
despite the sort of opposition that has derailed previous efforts.
Democratic Senator Charles Schumer said, “We believe this will be the
year Congress finally gets it done. The politics on this issue have been
turned upside down. For the first time ever, there is more political
risk in opposing immigration reform than supporting it.”
At the same press conference, Republican Senator John McCain said, “Now
we will again attempt to commit the remaining resources needed to secure
the border, modernize and streamline our current immigration system, and
create a tough but fair path to citizenship for those here illegally.”
Though the bipartisan Senate group includes influential Republicans such
as Florida Senator Marco Rubio, a potential 2016 Republican presidential
contender, organizations that opposed past reform efforts are not
Rosemary Jenks represents NumbersUSA, a group that says the Senate plan
is a rehash of past proposals that would offer amnesty for illegal
“The problem with amnesty is that if you send the message to the world
that, if you can come to the United States illegally and manage to break
the law for long enough, we will reward you with amnesty," she said. "So
the message is, 'Come on in.'”
The chairman of the House of Representatives Judiciary Committee, Lamar
Smith, also calls the new proposals an amnesty.
Despite the display of Senate bipartisanship, John Sides of George
Washington University says it is likely to take time for immigration
legislation to move forward on Capitol Hill.
timeline that ends in March strikes me as pretty ambitious. I don't
think that is because there is not a will to make this happen in
Congress. I just think it is a question of the natural slowness [of the
legislative process] and the need for different constituencies to buy
in," he said.
The Congressional Hispanic Caucus, whose members met with Obama last
week, called the Senate plan a positive step and expressed hope that
Republicans who control the House of Representatives will see it as
The American Civil Liberties Union said the Senate plan could help
protect illegal immigrants from exploitation by employers and discourage
racial profiling. But the liberal group is concerned about a requirement
for an electronic verification system, which it sees as “a thinly
disguised national ID requirement” that undermines privacy and imposes
new burdens on businesses.